$7

If you’re looking for an effortless fall lip combo, start with a good brown lip liner. NYX Professional Makeup’s Suede Matte Lip Liner has a velvety matte formula that glides on smoothly without tugging, making it easy to define and shape your lips. The formula is also highly pigmented, so you can wear it on its own or layer it underneath your favorite lipstick or gloss.

ExtraBucks Rewards: $6 ExtraBucks Rewards for purchasing 2 NYX Professional Makeup products

$10

If matte lip liners leave your lips feeling dry, Maybelline’s Lifter Liner fixes that. The creamy formula, infused with acid and jojoba oil, glides on smoothly without smearing or pulling for a more comfortable feel. It defines, contours, and enhances your lips’ natural shape while helping lock in moisture. Choose from 15 shades, including wearable nudes, browns, pinks, and deeper fall shades.

CVS Deal: $4.00 Off Maybelline New York—Any One (1) Maybelline New York Product (Excludes Expert Wear Eye Shadow Monos).

ExtraBucks Rewards: $8 ExtraBucks Rewards for spending $20 on Maybelline Cosmetics

$7

The ’90s lip is back, and the right lip liner is key for that slightly overlined, defined look. Milani Color Statement Lip Liner has a creamy, pigment-rich formula that glides onto lips to define, shape, and fill them, with a matte finish that works on its own or underneath lipstick. The sharpenable pencil also makes it easy to get a precise line, whether you’re following your natural lip shape or slightly exaggerating the edges.

ExtraBucks Rewards: $5 ExtraBucks Rewards for purchasing 2 Milani Cosmetics

$12

If you’re shopping for a lip liner that lasts through your morning coffee and the rest of the day, Revlon ColorStay Lip Liner is a classic drugstore pick. The formula is designed to last up to eight hours while helping prevent bleeding and feathering, making it the best pick when you want your lip color to stay defined. It also has a smooth finish that makes it easy to apply and layer with your favorite lipstick or gloss.

ExtraBucks Rewards: $5 ExtraBucks Rewards for spending $15 on Revlon Cosmetics or Beauty Tools (Excludes Super Lustrous)

$11

I’m not usually a fan of lip liners, but I keep the L’Oréal Colour Riche Liner stocked in my makeup bag. The liner doesn’t leave an uncomfortable feel behind and doesn’t wear off after eating or drinking. It also offers the most perfect rosy hue! I also appreciate the creamy formula, which defines and contours the lips while helping prevent feathering, and it’s infused with Omega-3 and vitamin E to condition and nourish your pout. I like using it to outline the lips, fill them in completely, or layer lipstick over top for more color.

CVS Deal: Buy 1, get 1 50% off
ExtraBucks Rewards: $5 ExtraBucks Rewards for spending $15 on L’Oréal Cosmetics

$2

There are affordable lip liners that offer a rich color payoff. That’s where the $2 e.l.f. Cream Glide Lip Liner comes in. Despite the tiny price tag, the creamy pencil has a high-pigment formula that glides on smoothly without tugging and leaves behind a semi-matte finish. Use it to outline and define your lips, fill them in completely, or wear it on its own.

The current range includes 13 shades, including several that are perfect for fall. Pick up Mocha Move, a neutral medium brown, and Espresso Martini, a cool taupe brown, to get ready for the season. There is also That Merlot Tho, which gives you a soft burgundy option.

$4

Wet n Wild’s Perfect Pout Gel Lip Liner is another drugstore lip liner worth adding to your fall makeup bag. The gel formula glides on smoothly and delivers highly pigmented color with a soft matte finish, defining your lips or filling them in completely before you add lipstick or gloss. Wet n Wild also says the formula is designed for long-lasting wear, making it best for when you don’t want to constantly touch up your lip combo.

CVS Deal: Buy 1, get 1 50% off

$5

This L.A. Girl lip liner is another affordable pick, with a hydrating gel formula that stays put. The gel formula glides on with creamy, full-coverage pigment and is smudge-proof, water-resistant, and long-wearing for up to eight hours. Use it to outline your lips or fill them in completely before adding lipstick or gloss.

CVS Deal: Buy 1, get 1 50% off