I am considering the definition of a tangent vector field ##\psi^{\mu}## to a timelike geodesic and slightly confused as to how it works for spacetimes.
If a curve is parametrised by some parameter ##\lambda##, the tangent to the curve is given by a four-vector ##dx^{\mu}/ d \lambda##, as expected for the equation for a tangent to a curve in a manifold, but I am not sure what happens with the ''time'' component of the tangent vector.
As an example, if we have flat Minkowski space and a massive particle in the space which follows a timelike geodesic whose spatial components are given by ##x_i = ( f_1 (t), f_2 (t), f_3(t))## such that the curve is parametrised by time, does that mean when you take the tangent vector ##\psi^{\mu}## that the zero component of the tangent four-vector vanishes, or is it constant?
Or is instead that the curve is timelike and parametrised by the proper time ##\tau## so that the spatial components of the tangent vector to the curve vanish (because it contains ##t## not ##\tau##) and the time component is constant?
Last edited by a moderator: Jan 15, 2025
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2024 Award
TimWilliams87 said:
I am considering the definition of a tangent vector field \psi^{\mu} to a timelike geodesic and slightly confused as to how it works for spacetimes.
Please fix your Latex: ##\psi^{\mu}##.
Two hashes either side of inline code. Two dollars either side for this;
$$E_0 = mc^2$$
TimWilliams87 said:
As an example, if we have flat Minkowski space and a massive particle in the space which follows a timelike geodesic whose spatial components are given by x_i = ( f_1 (t), f_2 (t), f_3(t)) such that the curve is parametrised by time, does that mean when you take the tangent vector $\psi^{\mu}$ that the zero component of the tangent four-vector vanishes, or is it constant?
The parameter ##\lambda## becomes the proper time, ##\tau##, for a timelike curve, but the ##t## component of a vector is the component parallel to the direction of increase of the coordinate time (in coordinate systems that have a time coordinate, of course). So the ##t## component of the four velocity would be ##dt/d\tau##.
Ibix said:
The parameter ##\lambda## becomes the proper time, ##\tau##, for a timelike curve, but the ##t## component of a vector is the component parallel to the direction of increase of the coordinate time (in coordinate systems that have a time coordinate, of course). So the ##t## component of the four velocity would be ##dt/d\tau##.
So does that mean the ##t## component of the tangent vector is constant (isn't ##dt/d\tau = 1##) and that the spatial components of the tangent vector finish (since they contain ##t## but the derivative is with respect to ##\tau##?
TimWilliams87 said:
So does that mean the ##t## component of the tangent vector is constant (isn't ##dt/d\tau = 1##)
##dt/d\tau## is the inverse time dilation factor. No, it is not 1 in general.
TimWilliams87 said:
the spatial components of the tangent vector finish (since they contain ##t## but the derivative is with respect to ##\tau##?
I assume you mean are the spatial components of the four velocity zero? No, clearly not - the position of the object is changing in general. If you want to know ##dx/d\tau## you need to write ##x(\tau)## or use the chain rule to get the derivative from ##x(t)##.
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2024 Award
Ibix said:
The parameter ##\lambda## becomes the proper time, ##\tau##, for a timelike curve, but the ##t## component of a vector is the component parallel to the direction of increase of the coordinate time (in coordinate systems that have a time coordinate, of course). So the ##t## component of the four velocity would be ##dt/d\tau##.
It is perfectly possible to use coordinate time ##t## as the curve parameter for a timelike curve. The tangent vector will have time component 1 and the vector therefore has norm < 1 (unless the spatial components all vanish). This means the vector is not the 4-velocity, but it is a tangent vector.
Orodruin said:
It is perfectly possible to use coordinate time ##t## as the curve parameter for a timelike curve. The tangent vector will have time component 1 and the vector therefore has norm < 1 (unless the spatial components all vanish). This means the vector is not the 4-velocity, but it is a tangent vector.
Right - I got four-velocity in my head instead of the more general tangent vector. Parameterised by coordinate time, the tangent vector has norm ##d\tau/dt## times that of the four velocity.
Ibix said:
Right - I got four-velocity in my head instead of the more general tangent vector. Parameterised by coordinate time, the tangent vector has norm ##d\tau/dt## times that of the four velocity.
Ok, since the four-velocity requires to employ the proper time ##\tau## along the timelike worldline as worldline's parameter.
Last edited: Jan 15, 2025
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
note: The 4-momentum is also a tangent vector. The “time component (according to an observer) of that 4-momentum” (a dot product with the observer 4-velocity) is associated with “energy of the particle according to that observer”.
| # | Наименование новости | Тональность | Информативность | Дата публикации |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Христофору: План премьера Латвии по выпуску БПЛА грозит войной с РФ | -7 | 5 | 30-06-2026 |
| 2 | ТАСС: ФСБ задержала директора фабрики "Златоуст" | 0 | 0 | 21-03-2025 |
| 3 | Северная Корея провела испытания крылатых ракет | 0 | 5 | 06-07-2026 |
| 4 | Друзья, российская промышленность продолжает уверенно наращивать обороты! Только в июне ... | 7 | 7 | 16-07-2026 |
| 5 | ТАСС: Дмитриев и Уиткофф прогулялись по Зарядью | 0 | 0 | 06-08-2025 |
| 6 | КОСМОС. МОНЕТЫ. Приднестровье 1 рубль, 2020 60 лет космическому полёту ... | 0 | 18.71 | 23-07-2026 |
| 7 | Глава 8. Жан-Батист Эммануэль Зорг застыл перед глупо мигающим таймером. ... | -2 | 7 | 11-07-2026 |
| 8 | Стычка между фанатами произошла на матче РПЛ "Зенит" - "Спартак" в Петербурге | 0 | 0 | 16-12-2020 |
| 9 | Филиппины, США и Япония провели учения в Южно-Китайском море | 0 | 15.13 | 26-07-2026 |
| 10 | Си Цзиньпин предложил президенту Филиппин постоянные тесные контакты по важным вопросам | 0 | 0 | 27-08-2021 |