Вход на сайт

Просмотр новости

Найдите то, что Вас интересует

Comment on Alman: German, Simplified. by Madeline Kalvis

Дата публикации: 26-07-2026 00:17:15

@David Eddyshaw
Welsh syntax doesn't seem too bad to me. The obvious differences, like main verbs before subjects and adjectives after nouns, are things that any English speaker will be familiar with in at least some contexts. Sometimes I will encounter "bod" halfway through a sentence and have to work backward to figure out the parallelism (i.e. "wait, was there a main verb waiting for a berfenw back there somewhere?"). But it's certainly no worse than any IE language that chains pieces together to make a verb phrase.
I think more consistent challenges for English speakers will be:
1. verbs so weathered by the centuries that their stems are hard to spot at first, like cael or mynd.
2. homophones in different parts of speech ("Bwytodd o llawer!" "Hmm? Bwytodd llawer o? Llawer o beth?")
3. fake forms that only exist in textbooks like "rydw i" for "dw i." Nothing sabotages a new learner more than well-meaning scholasticism in a textbook.

Основное содержимое страницы с новостью.

July 21, 2026 by languagehat

About:

Alman is a simplified dialect of German designed to reduce the complexity of the language while maintaining mutual intelligibility with Standard German. It systematically eliminates several complex grammatical features:

• Gender System: Uses a single article form for most contexts
• Case Markings: Removes most case-based inflections
• Noun Declensions: Simplifies noun endings across cases
• Job Titles: Eliminates gender-specific forms in occupational titles

The English home page opens with a deadpan Mark Twain riff:

In 1880, an American author filed a detailed complaint about the German language, together with a proposal for its reform. He had studied it for nine weeks, under great difficulty and annoyance; three of his teachers died in the meantime. The file has remained open since.

Just keep scrolling; it’s presented with all the interactive frills Youth Today are accustomed to, and I find it impressive and mildly amusing. I can’t quite believe someone went to all the trouble to create such an elaborate site in the service of a joke language, and I can’t quite escape the niggling suspicion that they don’t think it’s a joke.

I got to it via MetaFilter, where (as expected) some people don’t understand language and others don’t understand humor; I enjoyed Bruce Ware Allen’s comment quoting his grandfather describing a talk by Robert Millikan (“Introduced with words of strong praise, Millikan spoke a language which I have rarely heard, except from our own children – a German which knows no dative, and in which genders are distributed by lot”) and one by adrienneleigh beginning “When i was 16 or so, i read Samuel R. Delany’s Babel-17 (still one of the true books of my heart) and then, because of a tossed-off bit of trivia in it, set about to teach myself introductory Finnish.” Now, that’s my kind of reader!

Схожие новости

#Наименование новостиТональностьИнформативностьДата публикации
1 Comment on North American English Dialects. by languagehat 09.0825-07-2026
2 Comment on Two Bits from Y. by Madeline Kalvis 011.6426-07-2026
3Motion events in Takituduh Bunun and Holistic Spatial Semantics0717-07-2026
4I need some time to process this0716-07-2026
5A scoping review of 25 years of research on L2 English pronunciation (1996–2020)0814-07-2026
6Studies Show Most Adults Can't Pass A Baseline English Grammar Exam. Can You?0105-07-2026
7THE SHARPE END: Gareth Southgate's comment about Kalvin Phillips sounded ridiculous... but England ARE missing a midfielder in the 'Yorkshire Pirlo' mould and this who deserves a chance-2623-06-2024
8Reclaiming the classroom0523-04-2026
9"Euskaldunok erabaki behar dugu nola jokatu benetako harrera herria izan nahi badugu"0502-04-2019
10Человек думает словами. И чем беднее речь — тем беднее ...-15.8522-07-2026

Классификация: Мнения. Схожих патентов: 0. Схожих новостей: 10. Тональность: 0. Информативность: 8.74. Источник: languagehat.com.