Nasr Nasr held out for months. When customers would ask the Juice Dudez founder if he planned to make trompe-l’œil, the hyperrealistic fruit-shaped desserts crowding social media, he would redirect them to the smoothies and waffles already on the menu.

“When they started becoming trendy, a lot of people suggested we try it,” he said. “I kept saying, ‘No, we should stick to our strengths.’ Leave trompe-l’œil to pastry chefs. People train for years to get them right.”

Article content

Then he started tasting them.

Nasr drove between Montreal and Toronto, sampling fruit-shaped pastries wherever he could find them. Most were disappointing. “There was no real chocolate,” he said. “And they never tasted like actual fruit. Most of the time, I only tasted syrup.”

A juice bar, he decided, had an advantage. “Fruit is what we do best, so we had to take a stab at it.”

About 15 rounds of testing later, his ByWard Market shop had a trompe-l’œil mango, a speckled chocolate shell that cracks open to reveal chunks of fresh mango in mascarpone cream on a Lotus cookie base. It began selling out daily, “no matter how much we increase the production,” Nasr said.

At least five shops in Ottawa and Gatineau now make trompe-l’œil desserts. The trick on the eye is the same everywhere, but what each chef has decided to hide underneath is not.

Trompe-l’œil, French for “trick the eye,” describes a painting so convincing that a viewer may reach out to touch it. Renaissance painters made a discipline of the effect, and pastry chefs practise a similar illusion.

Chef Cédric Grolet gave the dessert its most famous template at Le Meurice in Paris, where he became head pastry chef in 2012. The hotel has France’s Palace distinction, a rating above five stars, and Grolet’s takeaway boutique sells a cornucopia of sculpted fruits at €18, or $28 CAD, a piece. His lemons are the calling card, a luxury pastry customers queue for and film themselves eating. In 2018, he took the World’s Best Pastry Chef title and his online following has grown to almost 14 million.

Article content

Elina Olefirenko, the pastry chef behind Elina Patisserie on Sussex Drive, says famous chefs have always pulled techniques back into fashion, although social media has sped up the process. Smaller shops interpret popular desserts so customers can try a pastry they’ve seen in France or Japan.

“In the industry, a few different chefs set the trends,” she said. “I didn’t plan to do trompe-l’œil. I thought the trend was already gone 10 years ago.”

She opened her shop in late 2022 after training at Le Cordon Bleu Ottawa to share her modern take on classic pastries. Customers began asking for the fruit-shaped pastries they had seen abroad and online.

Olefirenko made a trompe-l’œil pear “just to try” a mousse dessert with fruit filling and “a little chocolate shell,” and watched the videos play out in real time at her counter.

“Everybody was biting into it and showing the centre,” she said.

The illusion gave her pastries another way into the case. She shaped her lemon tart into the yellow fruit set on a sablé shell and whipped up the mousse from four or five kinds of citrus, peeling and segmenting lime, orange, grapefruit and bergamot to elevate the filling.

The cherry is an interpretation of Black Forest cake. Natural sour-cherry glaze covers chocolate tart, chocolate sponge, crémeux, cherries and vanilla mousse, though it has no hard chocolate casing.

Article content

“If it looks like a cherry to you,” she said, “then it’s a trompe-l’œil.”

The banana goes further into imitation with bruised skin over a caramelized version of the fruit, while the fig has the grainy centre of the real thing.

The acorn is one of her most technically demanding pieces. Beside her brighter fruit creations, the small brown shell can look modest, but inside Olefirenko has hidden Kyiv cake, a Ukrainian dessert from her childhood that she calls her favourite. Hazelnut meringue, praline, crème brûlée, coffee mousse and chocolate crunch are stratified under the shell. The filling is closer to a layered pastry than a single mousse.

The labour behind each trompe-l’œil is difficult to price and the margin can be thin.

“It’s more for the soul and the pride of the chef than for profit,” she said.

Before Sanaz Homa could perfect a fake raspberry in Ottawa, someone had to get the mould home from Paris.

A member of her staff found the shape while travelling and packed it into luggage for the trip back. Homa, the chef-owner of Tartelette, had already tried the usual routes. Canadian suppliers did not carry the fruit moulds she wanted. A cheap sample from China arrived in the wrong size and finish. The Italian brand she preferred came through a U.S. supplier.

Article content

“I bought about $600 of moulds and paid $180 just for the customs,” she said.

At her French-style bakery café in Old Ottawa East, Homa already had a full case to think about. Croissants, fruit tarts, cheesecakes, small cakes and daily pastries fill the display for customers who come in expecting her signature creations.

Homa tested the format first, repurposing a round, ornament-shaped mould left over from Christmas to make an orange before investing in pricier fruit shapes. Since launching last December, the $12 weekend-only orange has sold out within hours.

“We have lots of customers asking about other flavours, and bloggers always ask me, ‘Oh, why don’t you make this? Why don’t you make that?’” she said. “But I wanted to make sure it worked first. After that, I ordered more moulds.”

The orange also showed how much work each new fruit would demand. While the fruit is naturally juicy and fragrant, it lacks the structural body typically needed for a sturdy mousse.

“Orange doesn’t have much texture on its own. It’s not like strawberry, raspberry, or mango,” she explained. “Other chefs face this problem, so they often add another fruit — like yuzu, for example — to give it body and tartness. But I didn’t want to do that. I love the pure taste of orange, and I wanted to keep it as the sole flavour in the dessert.”

Article content

She worked on the recipe for six months. A simple orange confit could turn too sweet or watery, so Homa made the centre in parts: orange jelly for brightness, orange crémeux for body, orange mousse for lightness, sponge for structure and a chocolate shell dipped around the whole piece.

The pastry takes a full setup, from freezing the centres to spraying and dipping the shells, and Homa wants enough customers coming through to sell the batch while the texture is at its best.

“The most important thing to me at Tartelette is keep everything fresh,” she said.

A second Tartelette location is opening in Kanata in early July with a larger kitchen, brunch service, patio seating and more display space. Homa is using this extra pastry case room to expand her trompe-l’œil line, allowing customers to taste Tartelette’s take on strawberry, mango, coffee bean and the hard-won raspberry.

Joanne Yip and Kenny Xu spent four years selling tanghulu at Asian night markets — the first in Ottawa to offer the glazed fruit skewers, they say. Customers kept asking where to find their store. So they opened SpoonMii in the ByWard Market last November.

“He dragged me to do the markets,” said Yip. “I dragged him to do the store.”

Article content

Xu says they watch global pastry trends, then rework each one with Asian flavours.

“Aesthetic is very important,” he said. “And we also take our time to perfect the taste.”

That is how SpoonMii ended up with a mango that cracks like other trompe-l’œil desserts but hides a filling usually eaten with a spoon. Yip grew up in Hong Kong with mango sago, a chilled sweet soup of mango, coconut milk and tapioca pearls, and she wanted her version to stay true to the bowl.

“It’s in liquid form, like a soup, a sweet dessert soup,” she said. “I put my Hong Kong dessert inside to share my culture.”

Where other shops cook their mango filling into a gel, Yip leaves hers fresh, so the shell has to hold liquid without leaking. She uses halal beef gelatin instead of the usual pork, which sets differently — too little and the dessert leaks, too much and the softness is gone. Each mango takes three days to make.

Yip tried the spray gun professionals use to colour the white chocolate and didn’t like the finish, so she paints every shell by hand. The mould is a two-part design sourced through a Chinese manufacturer, and it takes twice as long to work with as the single moulds other shops use. During testing, the pair said they ate so many mangoes they couldn’t stand them for a while.

Article content

“Whenever I see people eating (our dessert), they’re happy,” Yip said. “It makes all my effort worth it.”

The tanghulu and the mango will always be on the menu, Yip said. An apple and a pear trompe-l’œil will be next, if they survive the same testing the mango went through — snow fungus with cooked and fresh pear in one, maybe pie filling in the other. She won’t rush either.

“We need to put time into them,” she said, “and try to perfect that taste, so on the first bite, people are going to love it.”

Lalie Borange had a case full of macarons before she made anything shaped like fruit.

She trained in Paris, at the Valrhona school and with chefs including Pierre Hermé, the man credited with making the modern macaron famous, before she opened Charlotte Macarons in Gatineau.

Her fruit-shaped desserts came much later. She added trompe-l’œil in January, after customers kept coming in with photos of the ones they had seen online.

“I take inspiration from French recipes, though I always adjust the sugar, since people lean toward what’s less sweet,” she said.

Her mango ($7.95) is the gentlest of the bunch. A thin shell breaks over mango cream and soft cake, more fresh than rich, which is where Borange wants to keep it.

Article content

“Something that looks like a mango should taste like a mango,” she said.

Borange is at her best with flavours she also sells as macarons. The pistachio filling tastes like a scoop of pistachio ice cream. Her raspberry could pass for a small cheesecake. The peanut has a crunchy, salty peanut butter filling that contrasts with the sweet cream under the shell.

Borange is working on a blueberry version for summer and will make strawberry again when Quebec strawberries are in season.

She puts about eight minutes of hands-on work into a single trompe-l’œil, and a batch of a few hundred can take four or five hours. The cream, the filling and the biscuit are made separately before she assembles each piece, freezes it and sprays the shell.

“It’s the cold of the chocolate that creates the effect,” she said. “Leave it in the car for an hour and you won’t get the crunch.”

The shells sweat the moment they leave the cold case. Borange advises customers to take their photo, get the dessert into the fridge within half an hour, and eat it cold.

Aside from her main store, Borange has a counter for her macarons and trompe-l’œil inside Espace Canevas. Some Saturdays she also crosses the river for the 613flea market at Lansdowne, though a lot of Ottawa has yet to find her.

Article content

“It really means a lot to support a small artisan tucked away in the corner,” she said.

For the juiciest bite, start with SpoonMii. The mango ($10.25) has an exciting centre, closer to fruit and coconut than pastry cream. The rest of the case has a similar sense of playfulness, including a tiramisu shaped like a coffee bean ($9.80).

For polish, go to Elina Patisserie. The banana ($14.50) is the showpiece for realism, down to the bruising on the peel, while the acorn is the one to order for Olefirenko’s most personal and technically layered trompe-l’œil creation.

For value and variety, Charlotte Macarons is the easiest recommendation. Borange’s raspberry ($7.95) is the pick among the fruit, while the peanut and pistachio show how good the format can be when it leaves fruit behind.

For citrus, Tartelette’s orange ($12) is worth a weekend trip, light and clean with a confit centre. When the Kanata location opens in July, Homa plans to put strawberry, raspberry, mango and coffee bean in the case.

And Juice Dudez is the one to watch next. Nasr has a strawberry version due any day, cut with rhubarb for tartness, and a surprise gelato trompe-l’œil planned for summer. He works with seasonal fruit, so each flavour disappears when its season ends.

“I’d rather you’re upset that we don’t have it than pay for it and not get the same experience,” he said.

Nasr said watching customer reactions from the counter gets him every time.

“Their eyes open wide as soon as they bite into it,” he said. “It’s the crunch. I think people love the crunch.”

Want to stay in the know about what’s happening in Ottawa? Sign up for the Citizen’s arts and life newsletter — Out of Office — our weekly guide to eating, listening, reading, watching, playing, hanging, learning and living well in the capital.

Article content